PHENOMENALITY: *uncanny*
MYTHICITY: *fair*
FRYEAN MYTHOS: *drama*
CAMPBELLIAN FUNCTIONS: *psychological*
SPOILERS
SPOILERS SPOILERS
At
this late date it’s hard to say how versed Bill Ballinger, the
screenwriter of THE STRANGLER, was in the still-ongoing case of the
Boston Strangler. Though an early specialist—what we now call a
“profiler”—theorized that the erratic serial killer might have
mother issues, I don’t have any idea if that theory was available
to Ballinger. For all I know, the writer may have chosen to model the
fictional character of Leo Kroll less on theories about Boston’s
serial murderer and more upon the template of Hitchcock’s Norman
Bates, who in turn had been partially patterned after Ed Gein.
In
PSYCHO, the audience never knows anything more about Norman’s
mother than what Norman relates. THE STRANGLER is more explicit: the
script and direction efficiently lay out exactly how badly Kroll
(Victor Buono) had been dominated by his invalid mother (Ellen Corby).
Her ongoing illnesses made it impossible for Kroll to sustain enough
capital to go to medical school, and so Kroll holds down a menial job
as a chemical researcher. In order to more surely bind her son to
her, the demanding Mrs. Kroll has repeatedly disparaged her obese
son’s appearance, implying that no woman could ever want him—and
though she claims to love him, there’s no sense that she has ever
tried to offer her son sensuous inducements to remain tied to her
apron strings, as one sees in certain iterations of Norman’s
mother. Kroll becomes a serial murderer of women for the same basic
reason as Norman does: frustrated sexuality. But whereas Norman
assumes his mother’s persona in an attempt to convince himself that
she’s jealous of Norman’s attentions, Kroll has no illusions of
becoming someone else. He can’t quite assert himself into
strangling his mother, but he can murder various nurses in the city
of his residence, as images of the manipulative crone. But he
evidently also sees his victims as emblems of feminine allure, for
before committing murder he patronizes a shooting gallery and always
wins a cute little doll for a prize. The script is a little vague on
what he does with the dolls—he only leaves one at the scene of a
strangling, thus giving the local cops a clue to his true nature. At
the same time that he’s killing so promiscuously, though, he has
one ideal real-
world woman he wants
to court, Tally, the young girl who manages the shooting gallery.
Ballinger’s
script devotes scant development to Tally, to Kroll’s other
victims, or to the cops who eventually track Kroll down. Te anatomy
of this particular psycho is the film’s only selling point. Unlike
a handful of other films based on the Boston Strangler, this one
creates an uncanny sense of the fearsome killer, rather than reducing
him to a predictable psychological “type.” Kroll’s doll-fetish
is the only aspect of his killings that gives them the vibe of the
uncanny “bizarre crime,” but Ballinger skillfully relates the
doll-motif to the killer’s unrealistic idealization of women. The
film’s only real surprise comes at the end, for though it sets up
the viewer to believe that the innocent Tally will be spared. The
cops, having ferreted out Kroll, want Tally to be a stalking-horse,
assuring her of their protection. Tally refuses, forcing the cops to
surveil her from a distance—which makes it possible for Kroll to
break in and strangle her before the cops can burst in and shoot him
down for a somewhat satisfying resolution.
Oddly,
in real life Albert de Salvo was jailed the same year that THE
STRANGLER saw release, and though he went to prison the law did not
in his lifetime validate his identity as the Boston Strangler.
DON’T
GO IN THE HOUSE was released one year after the mammoth success of
John Carpenter’s HALLOWEEN, but HOUSE doesn’t resemble the
majority of so-called slashers. It also declines to create any
mystery about the identity of the psycho-killer, and in this
resembles not PSYCHO but one of its same-year competitors, Michael
Powell’s PEEPING TOM. However, Donnie Kohler of HOUSE is one of the
most depressingly downscale psychos in American film.
Like
Norman Bates and Leo Kroll, Kohler is unable to forget his early
abuse, recapitulating it in his profession as a worker in a
waste-disposal plant. In his childhood his termagant mother—whose
husband apparently left her—picked up the habit of punishing young
Donny’s sins by holding his arms over a stove-fire. There’s not
much detail on the mother, but the broad implication is that she took
out her anger toward her absent husband on her child, not unlike the
mother of Stephen King’s Carrie White.
Unlike
Carrie, apparently Donnie manages to conceal his psychosis from the
waking world and gives the impression of being a functioning
adult—aside from one incident at his workplace, where he watches in
fascination when another worker’s body catches on fire. This
apparently tips Donnie over the edge, for in a scattershot manner he
begins looking for women to kill. Like Leo Kroll, Donnie’s not any
sort of charmer, so he has to rely on trickery and brute abduction,
as he decides to exorcise his sexual feelings by setting women on
fire—clearly an act of revenge against his deceased mother.
The
film recounts Donnie’s crimes in a documentary-like manner, showing
the big city as a place of low-income grit and grime. Like the psycho
in PEEPING TOM, Donnie retains some awareness of his hideous acts,
and even attempts to confess to a Catholic priest (possibly a symbol
of the absent father). This aspect of the killer’s personality
keeps his world within the context of the drama, in contrast to
PSYCHO’s universe of irredeemable irony. There are no clever cops
tracking down the killer this time: Donnie accidentally exposes
himself and brings about his own doom.
The
“delirious dreams” trope appears at the film’s end, when Donnie
hallucinates that some of the dead people in his life resurrect
themselves to haunt him prior to his death. The film’s darkest
touch appears in a coda, showing another little boy becoming warped
into psychosis by a heavy-handed mother—and thus suggesting that
the horrors of this house will go on, world without end.