PHENOMENALITY: *uncanny*
MYTHICITY: *fair*
FRYEAN MYTHOS: *irony*
CAMPBELLIAN FUNCTION: *metaphysical, psychological, sociological* Phenomenality first: the only reason this strange sex-farce rates as "uncanny" is because there are scenes in which adolescent protagonist Rick (Nat Wolff) and his simp-buddy Billy (Lachlan Buchanan) witness hot lady "saints" appear before them, and only to them, to dispense vague advice. It's not clear if these bizarre characters have any real existence in the world of the movie, though "Saint Lola" does give Rick some information about an event that has not yet transpired. That some psychological projection is also involved is suggested by the way each of the lady saints-- the other one's name being "Saint Poppy"-- looks exactly like each of the adolescent's respective mothers and are of course played by the same actresses playing those "real life" characters, Mary-Louise Parker and Elizabeth Shue. Source material second: BADLY, the only prominent credit by director/co-writer Tim Garrick, is based upon a 2000 comedic novel, WHILE I'M DEAD FEED THE DOG, and it's so referenced in the credits, though author Ric Browde publicly disavowed the adaptation. Having read a summation of the novel, all I can say is the movie does use some of the novel's comic concepts. Presumably because of the source material, BADLY has some unusual-- not to say superior-- deviations from the standard teen sex comedy. In teen comedies with one central protagonist, the hero is usually either a gormless innocent who gets in over his head but is essentially good-hearted, or a conniving "player" who seeks to manipulate older manipulators. Both are usually given serious-minded leading ladies who want the guys to clean up their acts so that they can be molded into decent boyfriend material. Not infrequently, there also exist "bad women" who serve to tempt the hero from the correct path. Sometimes the bad girls are skanks of the same age as the protagonist, but they can also be predacious older women. Antagonism to true love also takes the form of jealous boyfriends of the desired leading lady, or husbands of the predatory cougars.
One curious thing about BADLY is that it can't make up its mind as to which type the main character is. Sometimes he acts the part of the innocent caught up in designs beyond his ken. Then he often turns around and performs some manipulative action to gain the upper hand. Not a few online reviews found him "unlikable," and I concur, though the reason stems from the script wanting to have the character play off both of the main two stereotypes. The same ambivalence appears with regard to Rick's romantic goals. Although as a male teen Rick's beset by hormonal urges, he desires a girl his own age, classmate Nina (Selena Gomez), and though he lusts after her he also pictures her in an angelic fantasy. This would be the "madonna" part of the "madonna-whore" dichotomy of male desire identified by Freud, while the "whore" part is loosely ascribable all other women, not least Rick's mother Lucy (Parker). Lucy's not any sort of "predacious older woman," and there's no indication (except for his "Saint Lola" maybe-fantasy) that Rick is attracted to the womb that bore him. But Lucy and Rick's father don't live together anymore, and Lucy constantly signals familial chaos by complaining that one of these days she'll divorce her cheating husband. Arguably, any "older woman" intrigue is deflected onto Pamela (Shue), the mother of Rick's best friend Billy, and unlike a fair number of teen-hero protagonists, Rick does sleep with this predacious older woman. Rick also does errands for a sleazy guy at a strip club (a father-substitute perhaps), so Rick's no innocent, though the script can't make up its mind how blameless he is for his own situation. Amid all the random nonsense-situations in Rick's life, I find myself reflecting on whether or not, in contrast to most teen comedies, this one's source material may have taken the whole "whore complex" and ascribed it not just to three or four characters, but the nature of the sin-wracked world itself. Though Rick's major problems don't emphasize those standard tropes of "jealous boyfriend" or "jealous husband"-- they are there in the story, but very muted-- most of the males-- Rick's father, the strip club manager, various gangsters and even fathers of the Church-- are all drawn into the web of sin. Rick is clearly Catholic going by a scene where he makes confession, and implicitly Billy is too (though he doesn't have his "Saint Poppy" vision until the movie's end, just for a closing joke). Though one can't make broad generalizations about the actual practice of Catholic believers, I think that in fiction the Catholic faith is shown as having fetishized the "lust of the flesh" (1 John 2:16) so that it becomes the embodiment of the world's delusions, against which faith struggles. And in BEHAVING BADLY, this means a fleshy world where women hold much of the real control. Two other mature women pursue Rick, though not as avidly as Pamela, and she for good measure also has something going on with one of the local priests, so it's no surprise that she's the biggest "whore" in the movie. To be sure, even the "angelic" Nina, raised by fundamentalist parents, is clearly intrigued by Rick's ability to walk on the wild side. Is BADLY-- which I term an "irony" rather than a simple comedy-- a funny movie in any sense? Only fitfully, like an episode of FAMILY GUY. The producers managed to get a lot of recognizable names to contribute small parts-- Heather Graham, Dylan McDermot, Justin Beiber (in a cameo), Patrick Warburton, Cary Elwes, and Gary Busey. Of them all, Busey is slightly funny and of course Graham is unfailingly hot. But Elizabeth Shue has all the best scenes, some of which are very slapsticky in nature. In one scene, Pamela expects Rick to meet her in bed, and when a third party intrudes, she gets the unwelcome visitor in a crotch-grab that he clearly does not enjoy (though he pretends he does). Later, when a comely newslady comes on to Rick a little for an interview, Pamela tackles the competitor and gets summarily punched out. While drunk she even kisses on her own son a little, which goes a long while toward explaining why Billy, lacking an angel to "save" him, more or less turns gay.